Prospective design loads for bridges on automobile roads

published:
Number: Issue 29 (2024)
Section: Hydrotechnical construction, water engineering and water technology
The page spacing of the article: 251-272
Keywords: state building regulations, bridges, vehicles, loads.
How to quote an article: Inna Yermakova, Maksym Nechyporenko, Prospective design loads for bridges on automobile roads. Dorogi і mosti [Roads and bridges]. Kyiv, 2024. Issue 29. P. 251–272 [in Ukrainian].

Authors

State Enterprise «National Institute for Development Іnfrastructure» (SE «NIDI»), Kyiv, Ukraine
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2658-1857
State Enterprise «National Institute for Development Іnfrastructure» (SE «NIDI»), Kyiv, Ukraine
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5462-6947

Summary

Introduction. The article deals with the analysis and coverage of statistical data related to the development and application of temporary loads and the relevant norms for the design of bridge structures.

Problem Statement. Over the past 5-7 years, the highway bridges of Ukraine have undergone significant changes in the intensity and composition of traffic flows. At the same time, the load, which is established by the current regulations, does not take into account the tendency to increase the weight of cars. At the same time, a significant part of the building's life cycle takes place under conditions of overload, which leads to premature destruction and overspending on repairs.

In this regard, it is not always possible to unambiguously assign the type of calculated load, which can cause significant errors in the assessment of the strength and serviceability of bridge structures.

Materials and methods. Comparison of estimated vehicle loads of models H-10, H-13, H-18, NK-80, Н-30, NK-100, NG-60, A11, A15, AB-51, AB-74, AB-151 (from 1931 to 2023) with the LM1 model of Eurocode EN 1991-2 shows that there is some balance between the two. The estimated load according to Ukrainian standards is intermediate between the standards of Europe and the USA. However, the level of characteristic loads is almost twice as low as in the Eurocode. This is a significant shortcoming of state building regulations, as it reduces the level of reliability of calculations.

Results. The development of design standards and temporary loads of highway bridges is presented. The qualification of temporary loads acting on structures in Ukraine since 1931 has been completed. The stages of emergence and formation of load norms were analyzed. Conclusions are made regarding the evolution of design standards.

Conclusions. The classification and breakdown into stages of temporary loads acting on structures has been clarified. The stages of formation of calculated loads allow us to draw a conclusion about the possibility of their further exploitation. The article presents statistics on the design norms of loads on highway bridge structures. Based on the processing of historical data and current regulatory documents, taking into account the real tendency to overload vehicles, possible values of temporary loads from rolling stock, which will be relevant for the future period of 20, 50 and 100 years, are determined.

References

  1. Pro pryiednannia do Uhody pro masy i habaryty transportnykh zasobiv, shcho zdiisniuiut mizhderzhavni perevezennia avtomobilnymy dorohamy derzhav – uchasnyts Spivdruzhnosti Nezalezhnykh Derzhav: Decree of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine dated 10/29/1999 No. 2020. /Baza danykh Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy/ Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy/ URL: https://zakon.rada. gov.ua/laws/show/2020-99-%D0%BF#Text  (Last accessed: 28.02.20024) [in Ukrainian].
  2. DBN V.1.2‑15:2009. Mosty ta truby. Navantazhennia i vplyvy. (DBN V.1.2‑15:2009 Bridges and pipes. Loads and influences). Kyiv, 2009. 84 p. (Information and documentation) [in Ukrainian].
  3. DBN V.2.3‑26:2009. Mosty ta truby. Stalevi konstruktsii (DBN V.2.3‑22:2009 Bridges and pipes. Basic design requirements). Kyiv, 2009. 73 p. (Information and documentation) [in Ukrainian].
  4. Mosty ta truby. Stalevi konstruktsii (DBN V.2.3‑26:2009. Bridges and pipes. Steel structures). Kyiv, 2009. 266 p. (Information and documentation) [in Ukrainian].
  5. DBN V.1.2‑14:2018. Systema zabezpechennia nadiinosti ta bezpeky budivelnykh obiektiv.
    Zahalni pryntsypy zabezpechennia nadiinosti ta konstruktyvnoi bezpeky budivel i sporud (DBN V.1.2‑14:2018. The system for ensuring the reliability and safety of construction objects. General principles of ensuring the reliability and structural safety of buildings and structures). Kyiv, 2018. 36 p. (Information and documentation) [in Ukrainian].
  6. DBN V.2.3-14:2006. Mosty ta truby. Pravyla proektuvannia (DBN V.2.3-14:2006. Bridges and pipes. Design rules). Kyiv, 2006. 365 p. (Information and documentation) [in Ukrainian].
  7. DSTU-N B V.2.3-23:2009. Nastanova z otsiniuvannia i prohnozuvannia tekhnichnoho stanu avtodorozhnikh mostiv. Minrehionbud Ukrainy (DSTU-N B V.2.3-23:2009. Guidelines for assessing and predicting the technical condition of highway bridges. Ministry of Regional Development of Ukraine). Kyiv, 2009. 54 p. [in Ukrainian].
  8. SNyP 2.05.03-84 Mosty i truby (SNiP 2.05.03-84 Bridges and pipes). M., 1986. 277 p. [in Ukrainian].
  9. SN-200-62. Tekhnichni umovy proektuvannia zaliznychnykh, avtodorozhnikh ta miskykh mostiv i trub (CH-200-62. Technical conditions for the design of railway, road and urban bridges and pipes). M., 1962. 324 p. [in Ukrainian].
  10. N-106-53. Normy rukhomykh vertykalnykh navantazhen dlia rozrakhunku shtuchnykh sporud na avtomobilnykh dorohakh (H-106-53. Norms of moving vertical loads for the calculation of artificial structures on highways) M., 1953. 17 p. [in Ukrainian].
  11. Tekhnichni umovy na sporudzhennia avtomobilnykh shliakhiv Hushosdora NKVS (Technical conditions for the construction of highways of Gushosdor NKVD). Moscow, 1938.
  12. Tekhnichni umovy 1931 r. Tsudortrans NKShS (Technical conditions of 1931 Tsudortrans NKSHS). Moscow, 1931 [in Ukrainian].
  13. Luchko Y. Y., Koval P. M., Korniev M. M., Lantukh-Lyashchenko A.I., Kharkhalis. Mosty: konstruktsii ta nadiinist (M.R. Bridges: structures and reliability). Lviv, 2005. 989 p.
  14. Korniiev M. M. Stalevi mosty (Steel bridges). 3 Toma, Kyiv, 2018. 423 р. [in Ukrainian].
  15. Strakhova N. Ye., Holubiev V. O., Kovalov P. M., Todirika V. V. Ekspluatatsiia i rekonstruktsiia mostiv (Operation and reconstruction of bridges). 2nd edition. corrections. Kyiv, 2002. 408 р. [in Ukrainian].
  16. Kudriavtsev. A.S. Narysy z istorii dorozhnoho budivnytstva v SRSR (dozhovtnevyi period) (Essays on the history of road construction in the USSR (pre-October period)), 1951. 332 р. [in Ukrainian].
  17. Riapukhin V. M. Obgruntuvannia rozrakhunkovoho navantazhennia na mahistralnykh dorohakh Ukrainy (Justification of the calculated load on the main roads of Ukraine) [in Ukrainian].
  18. EN 1990: Eurocode – Basis of structural design [Authority: The European Union Per Regulation 305/2011, Directive 98/34/EC, Directive 2004/18/EC]. English 2002. 119 р. [in English].
  19. EN 1991‑2: Eurocode 1: Actions on structures – Part 2: Traffic loads on bridges [Authority: The European Union Per Regulation 305/2011, Directive 98/34/EC, Directive 2004/18/EC]. English 2003. 167 р. [in English].
  20. AASHTO LRFD BRIDGE (American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials) Design Specification. 2012 [in English].
  21. G. Sedlacek, G. Merzenich, M. Paschen, A. Bruls, L. Sanpaolesi, P. Croce, J.A. Calgaro, M. Pratt, Jacob, M. Leendertz, v. de Boer, A. Vrouwenfelder, G. Hanswille. Background document to EN 1991‑ Part 2 ‑ Traffic loads for road bridges – and consequences for the design, First Edition, XXXXX 2008. 324 р. [in English].
  22. EN 1991‑1‑1: Eurocode 1: Actions on structures – Part 1‑1: General actions – Densities, self‑weight, imposed loads for buildings [Authority: The European Union Per Regulation 305/2011, Directive 98/34/EC, Directive 2004/18/EC]. English 2003. 47 р. [in English].
  23. Background document to EN 1991- Part 2 – Traffic loads for road bridges – and consequences for the design, G. Sedlacek, G. Merzenich, M. Paschen, A. Bruls, L. Sanpaolesi, P. Croce, J. A. Calgaro, M. Pratt, Jacob, M. Leendertz, v. de Boer, A. Vrouwenfelder, G. Hanswille. First Edition, 2008 [in English].
  24. Na dorogah Ukrainy kozhna druga fura perevantazhena – Kriklij  (On the roads of Ukraine, every second truck is overloaded – Krykliy) URL: https://golos.ua/news/na-dorogah-ukrainy-kazhdyj-vtoroj-gruzovik-peregruzhen-kriklij (Last accessed: 28.02.20024) [in Ukrainian]
  25. Na trasi pid Poltavoyu policiya zupinila rekordno perevantazhenu 70-tonnu vantazhivku. (On the highway near Poltava, the police stopped a record overloaded 70-ton truck.) URL: https://poltava.to/news/53104/ (Last accessed: 28.02.20024) [in Ukrainian].
  26. Ternopilshinoyu ruhalasya vantazhivka z prichepom vagoyu u 200 (!) tonn. (A truck with a trailer weighing 200 (!) tons was moving through Ternopil region.) URL: https://www.gazeta1.com/statti/ ternopilshhynoyu-ruhalosya-vantazhivka-z-prychepom-vagoyu-u-200-tonn/ (Last accessed: 28.02.20024) [in Ukrainian].
  27.  She odin «record» v Odesi, zatrimali vantazhivku z p'yatikratnim perevantazhennyam. (Another «record» in Odessa, a truck with five times overload was detained). URL: https://odessa. net.ua/news/esche-odin-rekord-v-odesse-zaderzhali-furu-s-pjatikratnym-peregruzom (Last accessed: 28.02.20024) [in Ukrainian].