Justification of implementing self-regulating roundabouts on the urban road network of the city

published:
Number: Issue 30(2024)
Section: Transport technology
The page spacing of the article: 389-397
Keywords: microsimulation, PTV Vissim, capacity, roundabout, signalized intersection.
How to quote an article: Volodymyr Tarasiuk, Dmytro Bespalov, Vitalii Tereshchuk, Mykhailo Korol. Justification of implementing self-regulating roundabouts on the urban road network of the city. Dorogi і mosti [Roads and bridges]. Kyiv, 2024. Issue 30. P. 389–397 [in Ukrainian].

Authors

Kyiv National University of Construction and Architecture, Kyiv, Ukraine
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0778-5627
LLC “Bespalov Lab”, Kyiv, Ukraine
https://orcid.org/0009-0002-2831-7969
LLC “Pro Mobility”, Kyiv, Ukraine
https://orcid.org/0009-0005-8073-1683
Kyiv National University of Construction and Architecture, Kyiv, Ukraine
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4762-5668

Summary

Introduction. In the modern world, the transport infrastructure of cities faces significant challenges related to the growth of traffic intensity, congestion and the need to ensure road safety. Among the wide range of engineering solutions and technologies aimed at solving these problems, it is worth highlighting the issue of justifying the choice of planning solutions in places of the highest concentration of traffic flows - transport hubs. International experience shows that the construction of roundabouts is one of the ways to optimize traffic, reduce congestion and improve road safety. Therefore, it is important to consider this type of planning solutions for transport hubs in terms of the feasibility of their use on the city's street and road network.

Problem Statement. One of the main principles of traffic management at high-intensity intersections is the arrangement of signalized or roundabouts. In the conditions of dense urban development, the issue of justifying the choice of intersection design solutions is of particular relevance, because due to the significant cost per unit area of urban territory, its alienation for a transport infrastructure element is a very complex issue, the solution of which requires a comprehensive assessment of all options using various methods for evaluating the choice of intersection design solutions on the city road network. One of these methods is microsimulation, which can be used to calculate LOS (Level of Service), transport and operational, environmental and energy characteristics, etc. within individual elements of the road network. Despite the considerable attention paid to the design of roundabouts and regulated intersections in domestic regulatory documents and scientific research, there is currently no clear argumentation to justify the choice of their planning solutions. In this regard, it is important to assess the effectiveness of both types of planning solutions depending on changes in traffic intensity within them in order to obtain the main indicators of their performance for further consideration when justifying the choice of planning solutions for transport hubs.

Purpose. Analysis of efficiency, determination of advantages and disadvantages of planning solutions of transport hubs by the type of roundabout and signalized intersection.

Materials and methods. The main way to analyze the effectiveness of planning decisions is to use microsimulation using specialized software PTV Vissim.

Results. Using the PTV Vissim software, analysis and collection of transport performance indicators within a roundabout and a signalized intersection were carried out.

Conclusions. The feasibility of arranging roundabouts can be substantiated on the basis of calculated indicators obtained using a microsimulation tool, including the number of vehicles that passed through the intersection, time delays, and traffic speed. As a result of the experiment, it was found that with the intensity of incoming traffic flows in the range of 1 500...3 000 vehicles per hour, the number of vehicles passing through both the signalized intersection and the roundabout almost does not change (the difference varies within 3 – 6 %). At the same time, the difference in the absolute number of vehicles passing through the roundabout is 26 – 33 % higher (depending on the intensity of the incoming traffic flow) than the number of vehicles passing through the signalized intersection.

References

  1. Osietrin M. M. Miski dorozhno-transportni sporudy. Navchalnyi posibnyk dlia studentiv VNZ (City road and transport facilities. Study guide for university students). Kyiv, 1997. 196 р. [in Ukrainian].
  2. Lutsenko O. V. Faktory, yaki vyznachaiut vybir inzhenerno-planuvalnykh rishen peretyniv miskykh mahistralei z kiltsevym rukhom . Mistobuduvannia ta terytorialne planuvannia: nauk.-tekhn (Factors that determine the choice of engineering and planning solutions for intersections of city highways with circular traffic). zbirnyk. Vyp. 58. Kyiv. Р. 354–34 [in Ukrainian].
  3. Samorehulovane kiltseve perekhrestia: Metodychni vkazivky do vykonannia kursovoho i dyplomnoho proektuvannia (Self-regulating roundabout: Methodical instructions for course and diploma design). Kyiv, 2004. 52 р. [in Ukrainian].
  4. HBN V.2.3-37641918-555:2016 Avtomobilni dorohy. Transportni rozviazky v odnomu rivni. Proektuvannia. K.: Ministerstvo infrastruktury Ukrainy (Автомобільні дороги. Транспортні розв’язки в одному рівні. Проектування), 2011. 58 р. (Informatsiia ta dokumentatsiia) [in Ukrainian].
  5. Bondar O. V. Kryterii otsiniuvannia inzhenerno-planuvalnykh rishen peretyniv miskykh mahistralnykh vulyts z kiltsevym rukhom transportu. Visnyk Odeskoi derzhavnoi akademii budivnytstva ta arkhitektury (Criteria for evaluating engineering and planning solutions for intersections of city main streets with circular traffic). Vyp. 65. Odesa, 2016. Р. 3–9 [in Ukrainian].
  6. Huk V. Y. Еlementі teoryy transportnиkh potokov y proektyrovanyia ulyts y doroh (Elements of the theory of traffic flows and street and road design). Navchalnyi posibnyk. Kyiv. 1991. 255 р. [in Ukrainian].
  7. Driu D. Teriia transportnykh potokiv ta upravlinnia nymy (Theory of traffic flows and their management). 1972. 424 р. [in Ukrainian].
  8. Xinyi Yang A Service Life Analysis of Roundabouts Retrofits for Signalized Intersections. Procedia Engineering. Procedia Engineering 145 ( 2016 ). Р. 452–459 р. [in Ukrainian].
  9. Fornalchyk Ye. Yu. Upravlinnia dorozhnim rukhom na rehulovanykh perekhrestiakh u mistakh: monohrafiia (Traffic management at controlled intersections in cities: monograph), Lviv, 2018.  236 р. [in Ukrainian].
  10. Lytvyn V. V. Obgruntuvannia efektyvnosti zastosuvannia kiltsevoho rukhu na vulychno-dorozhnii merezhi m. Dnipro u prohramnomu seredovyshchi PTV VISSIM (Justification of the effectiveness of the use of circular traffic on the street and road network of the city of Dnipro in the PTV VISSIM software environment). Suchasni tekhnolohii v mashynobuduvanni ta transporti. Dnipro, 2019. Р. 95–107 [in Ukrainian].
  11. DBN V.2.3-5-2018 Vulytsi ta dorohy naselenykh punktiv. (Streets and roads of populated areas) Kyiv, 2018. 61 р. (Informatsiia ta dokumentatsiia) [in Ukrainian].
  12. DBN V.2.3-5-2001 Sporudy transportu. Vulytsi ta dorohy naselenykh punktiv (Transport structures. Streets and roads of settlements). Kyiv, 2001. 51 р. (Informatsiia ta dokumentatsiia) [in Ukrainian].
  13. DSTU 4092-2002 Bezpeka dorozhnoho rukhu. Svitlofory dorozhni. Zahalni tekhnichni vymohy, pravyla zastosovuvannia ta vymohy bezpeky (Road traffic safety. Traffic lights. General technical requirements, application rules and safety requirements). Kyiv, 2003. 27 р. (Informatsiia ta dokumentatsiia) [in Ukrainian].
  14. VISSIM 14 Fundamentals, VISSIM 14 Manual, 2014 PTV AG, Karlsruhe. URL: https://www.scribd.com/document/705998759/Vissim-2024-Manual  (data zvernennia 03.09.2024) [in English].