Review of methodological approaches to planning maintenance work for road network operations

published:
Number: Issue 30(2024)
Section: Construction and civil engineering
The page spacing of the article: 114-121
Keywords: road, maintenance, scope of work, work list, work planning, operational condition, limited funding, repair work
How to quote an article: Sergii Illiash, Tetiana Stasiuk. Review of methodological approaches to planning maintenance work for road network operations. Dorogi і mosti [Roads and bridges]. Kyiv, 2024. Issue 30. P. 114–121 [in Ukrainian].

Authors

State Enterprise «National Institute for Development Infrastructure» (SE «NIDI»), Kyiv, Ukraine
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3001-8012
State Enterprise «National Institute for Development Infrastructure» (SE «NIDI»), Kyiv, Ukraine
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5921-4503

Summary

Introduction. The development of Ukraine's road network under current conditions is characterized by limited funding for road maintenance. At the same time, determining the scope and list of works based on the actual operational condition of the roads is extremely important, as it significantly affects the safety and comfort of road users, as well as the efficiency of vehicle operation. A standard norm is used to determine the planned scope of work, which is averaged for roads of the corresponding category. This simplifies calculations, but such an approach does not precisely establish the annual planned volumes of maintenance work for a specific section, as it does not consider its actual operational condition. Given the current level of funding, it is relevant to develop a methodology for determining the planned volumes and lists of maintenance work that is accurate enough, but does not require significant costs for road section inspections. 

Problem Statement. The determination of the scope of maintenance work is based on a comprehensive analysis of the road surface condition, forecasted traffic loads, and the allocation of budgetary resources. However, under martial law, the country’s priorities have shifted, with the focus on ensuring state defense, providing humanitarian aid, etc. Based on the current trends in the development of Ukraine’s road industry, the main task is the rational use of limited financial resources and maintaining roads in proper operational condition. 

The standards for the scope of maintenance work are approved in accordance with the Methodology for Determining the Funding for Road Construction, Reconstruction, Repair, and Maintenance (hereinafter — the Methodology) [1] and are averaged across Ukraine. According to this standard, a specific list and volume of works for 1 km of a national category II road is set, which is adjusted by correction coefficients and the length of the corresponding category sections to fit the required network, but does not take into account their actual operational condition. National roads usually have higher traffic intensity compared to local roads. Also, newly repaired roads significantly differ in operational condition from those that have not undergone repair for an extended period. Therefore, establishing a differentiated approach to updating the volumes of maintenance work for national and local roads is extremely important. 

Objective. To analyze the effectiveness of applying existing methods for determining the planned scope of road network maintenance work under current conditions. 

Materials and Methods. This article is a review. A systematic approach was used, which represents a set of general scientific methodological principles (requirements) based on the consideration of objects as systems. 

Results. Analyzing existing methods for determining the scope and lists of road network maintenance work will allow the identification of their main advantages and disadvantages, as well as possible directions for improvement or the introduction of new approaches. 

Conclusions. Planning maintenance work under conditions of limited resources is a complex task that requires a comprehensive approach and the use of modern methods and technologies. Proper planning and rational resource use will ensure the effective maintenance of roads and the preservation of their functional characteristics in the future. Considering this, it is advisable to improve the mechanism for determining the planned volumes and lists of maintenance work, while maintaining its simplicity. 

References

  1. Pro zatverdzhennia Metodyky vyznachennia obsiahu finansuvannia budivnytstva, rekonstruktsii, remontu ta utrymannia avtomobilnykh dorih ta normatyviv vytrat, poviazanykh z utrymanniam avtomobilnykh dorih (On the approval of the Methodology for determining the amount of funding for the construction, reconstruction, repair and maintenance of highways and standards of costs related to the maintenance of highways): Nakaz vid 21.09.2012 No. 573/1019 / Baza danykh Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy // Verkhovna rada Ukrainy. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z1734-12#n180 (data zvernennia 09.09.2024) [in Ukrainian].
  2. Postanova kabinetu ministriv Ukrainy. Deiaki pytannia vykorystannia zalyshku koshtiv, vyznachenoho punktom 2 statti 36 Zakonu Ukrainy “Pro Derzhavnyi biudzhet Ukrainy na 2024 rik” (Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. Some issues of using the balance of funds
    determined by clause 2 of Article 36 of the Law of Ukraine "On the State Budget of Ukraine for 2024) vid 23.02.2024 No. 199 / Baza danykh Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy // Verkhovna rada Ukrainy. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/ 199-2024-%D0%BF#Text (data zvernennia 10.09.2024) [in Ukrainian].
  3. DSTU 8747:2017 Avtomobilni dorohy. Vydy ta pereliky robit z remontiv ta ekspluatatsiinoho utrymannia (Automobile roads. Types and lists are made of repairs and operational maintenance). Kyiv, 2017. 34 p. (Informatsiia ta dokumentatsiia) [in Ukrainian].
  4. Raikovskyi V.F. Udoskonalennia metodu rozrakhunku nadiinosti nezhorstkoho dorozhnoho odiahu pry dii navantazhennia (Improvement of the method of calculating the reliability of non-rigid road clothing under load action): avtoref. dys…. kand. tekh. Nauk. Kyiv, 2021. 22 p. [in Ukrainian].
  5. Komanda “Velykoho budivnytstva” predstavyla novu rozumnu systemu keruvannia yakistiu dorih E-ROAD (The "Great Construction" team presented a new smart E-ROAD road quality management system). URL: https://lviv-rda.gov.ua/komanda-velykoho-budivnytstva-predstavyla-novu-rozumnu-systemu-keruvannya-yakistyu-dorih-e-road. (data zvernennia 10.09.2024) [in Ukrainian].
  6. НDM-4 is a software package and associated documentation which will serve as the primary tool for the analysis, planning, management and appraisal of road maintenance, improvements and investment decisions. URL: https://www.piarc.org/en/PIARC-knowledge-base-Roads-and-Road-Transportation/Road-Safety-Sustainability/Road-Assets-Management/HDM-4-Software (data zvernennia 10.09.2024) [in English].